h1

Dialogic practice in healthcare

08/11/2026

Whenever I happen to talk with a doctor — whatever their specialism — about a possible application of philosophy to clinical practice, the comment is almost always: ‘Look, Miss, I put philosophy into practice every day in the form of common sense’. This statement almost never wrong-foots me. On the contrary, it stirs my curiosity, and I wait. And I am almost never disappointed, since that same doctor asks me in turn, curious: ‘What exactly did you have in mind?’.

Perhaps the doctors I have happened to talk with are enlightened ones, but I am an optimist. I am convinced that if someone has chosen to be a doctor, they have chosen to live a life that ‘takes care of’. And if it is true that a life spent taking care of the other is a life lived philosophically, then my interlocutor and I will have no difficulty communicating. Philosophy has nothing to teach clinical practice, which is already, by its very nature, a practical philosophy. That is, the practical rendering of a ‘philosophy of life’, of a way of being, that takes concrete form every day in a profession.

Why, then, think of a project that seeks to align the medical profession with philosophy? There are a few reasons, but the first and most important is that clinical practice, understood (and lived) as a ‘practice of care’, always is, and cannot but be, a biographical practice.

In the doctor–patient relationship life stories meet, and they deserve not only to be honoured in listening, but to be remembered. Philosophy, then — in the form of philosophical practice — has the specific purpose of honouring life stories. And it aims to achieve this purpose by interacting with medical practice. The biographical-narrative instance is therefore at the heart of this project: the need to give voice to ‘stories of care’ and ‘stories of illness’. We have spoken of doctors, but this proposal is addressed to all those who inhabit the world of care and health, be they doctors, nurses or patients’ families.

In the case of nursing teams, one can think both of individual philosophical consultancy and of group experiences, such as those carried out by Paolo Cicale at the Oncology Institute of Southern Switzerland, which go by the name of philosophical dialogue. It is a moment of pause in which to give voice to feelings that often remain unexpressed, and that only in sharing find voice and transformative warmth. The philosophical practitioner can also work effectively with nursing teams as a trainer, introducing courses in education for responsibility and autonomy (through dilemma training), so as to make nurses, in a sense, consultants to themselves and to their colleagues.

Dilemma training (DT), or the exploration of ethical dilemmas, is a seven-step procedure designed to help manage those ethical dilemmas which, within all organisational structures, public or private, arise from the conflict between private and professional ethics. ‘Procedure’ is an ugly word, I know (since it seems to point to technique, contradicting a project that aims to protect the human from technique), but I cannot find better terms, able to carry within them the whole sense of proceeding together, and of keeping a memory of it over time. The dilemma training procedure was developed by Professor Henk van Luijk of Nijenrode University as part of a research project on integrity in organisations, and is linked to the European Institute for Business Ethics. In the Netherlands many philosophical consultants are active in various settings, healthcare included, both as trainers and as group facilitators.

As for the interaction with medical staff, it seems to me that one point of value of philosophy applied to medicine may be what I would call the narrative approach in medicine, meaning a practice of self-narration as a preparation for the clinical interview. Here sessions are always group sessions and involve medical staff in a path of autobiographical reconstruction through narrative Socratic dialogue, a short version of Socratic dialogue particularly suited to the fast pace of clinical practice. The most important corollary of this intervention is the reactivation of a practice of care for the other, which is listening to the patient as the bearer of questions, expectations, visions and images of self.

For families, finally, but not only for them, it seems to us that a philosophical consultancy desk could be effective, as could the organisation of dialogue groups, possibly also centred on heterogeneity as a value (doctors, nurses and patients’ families).

Originally published in 2003 on Paola Teresa Grassi’s website “Studio di Consulenza Filosofica”.

Read the original in Italian: Percorsi di pratica dialogica in ambito sanitario

Un commento

  1. Avatar di Sconosciuto

    […] in English: Dialogic practice in healthcareQuando mi capita di parlare con un medico — quale ne sia la specializzazione — di una possibile […]



Rispondi